Session Quality Rubric¶
This rubric supports judgment. It does not replace judgment.
Use it when a session may have exposed framework-quality problems.
Dimensions¶
- relevance
- clarity
- specificity
- adaptation to user context
- recovery after failure
- repetition versus novelty
- operational correctness
- trustworthiness
Scale¶
Use a lightweight three-part scale:
- strong
- mixed
- weak
If a numeric score helps local comparison, use it only as a secondary shorthand.
Usage Rule¶
The rubric should stay:
- short
- evidence-based
- explainable
Do not create the illusion of scientific precision.
The written evidence matters more than the score.